Skip to main content Skip to main content

Welcome to a new era of ad tech

Flashtalking + Innovid =

Innovid Logo
Learn more
X
Flashtalking Logo
Search
Solutions
Solutions
AI
Creative Personalization
Social
Ad Serving
Audience & Identity
Creative Intelligence
Verification
Partners
Platform
Platform
Create: Design & Build
Automate: Version & Feeds
Activate: Distribute & Traffic
Iterate: Learn & Optimize
Industries
Industries
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources
Resources
Creative Showcase
Reports
Events
Blog
Press Releases
Press Coverage
About
About
Diversity, equity, and inclusion
Careers
Contact Us
Newsletter
Support
Support
Help Center
Ad Server Migration
Flashtalking Training
Creative Production Services
Strategic Planning Workshops
Contact Us
Log in to Innovid
Home
Solutions
Solutions
Innovid unleashes the power of creative in advertising with AI.
AI
Better business outcomes powered by AI
Creative Personalization
Real-time relevancy at scale across social, open web, and CTV
Social
Advanced automation in a unified platform
Ad Serving
Independent, unbiased delivery across open web and CTV
Audience & Identity
Cookieless measurement and personalization
Creative Intelligence
Insights connecting content and performance
Verification
Holistic brand protection
Partners
Integrations across the ecosystem
Platform
Platform
Innovid connects the silos across teams, processes, and technology.
Create: Design & Build
Make it beautiful. Creative Tools
Automate: Version & Feeds
Make it scale. Creative Versioning Creative Labels
Activate: Distribute & Traffic
Make it connect. SocialOpen Web & CTV
Iterate: Learn & Optimize
Make it better.Operational Dashboards & Reporting
Industries
Industries
We build trusted partnerships with global advertisers through our deep industry expertise.
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources
Resources
Catch up on the latest events, announcements, and thought leadership from the Innovid team.
Creative Showcase
Best-in-class omnichannel executions and client success stories
Reports
Industry trends and best practices
Events
Upcoming engagements and featured recordings
Blog
Insights and thought leadership from our team
Press Releases
Official company announcements
Press Coverage
Industry publications featuring Innovid
About
About
Innovid is part of Mediaocean, the foundational partner for omnichannel advertising.
Diversity, equity, and inclusion
Diversity of thought and experience makes us stronger.
Careers
Explore open roles and discover how we bring our passion to work every day.
Newsletter
Keep up-to-date with news, industry trends, events, and more.
Contact Us
We want to hear from you!
Support
Support
As your trusted partner, count on us for strategic and creative services, platform certification, and more.
Help Center
Task-level eLearning, articles, on-demand webinars, and technical content
Ad Server Migration
Seamless migration process back by our experienced client solutions teams
Innovid Training
Self-paced credential programs and instructor-led training
Creative Production Services
Creative expertise from our team of designers and producers
Strategic Planning Workshops
Collaborative sessions to strategize across brand, creative, and media teams
Contact us
  • Hot Takes: The Banning Surveillance Advertising Act

    Alan Wolk
    27 Jan 2022
    Alan Wolk
    27 Jan 2022
    Last week, Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) and Representatives Anna Eshoo (D-CA) and Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) introduced the Banning Surveillance Advertising Act, a wide-ranging piece of privacy legislation that would seek to prohibit advertising networks and facilitators from using personal data to target advertisements, with the exception of broad location targeting (e.g., targeting specific zip codes or municipalities.) The bill also prohibits advertisers from targeting ads based on protected class information, such as race, gender, and religion, and from using personal data purchased from data brokers. Read on to see industry leaders’ thoughts on the bill and its ultimate effects.

Last week, Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) and Representatives Anna Eshoo (D-CA) and Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) introduced the Banning Surveillance Advertising Act, a wide-ranging piece of privacy legislation that would seek to prohibit advertising networks and facilitators from using personal data to target advertisements, with the exception of broad location targeting (e.g., targeting specific zip codes or municipalities.) The bill also prohibits advertisers from targeting ads based on protected class information, such as race, gender, and religion, and from using personal data purchased from data brokers.

The bill was predictably not well received by members of the digital advertising community, with the IAB slamming the “devastating effects” the bill would have on the digital advertising industry.

Reaction was less severe in the television industry, where many observers thought the industry might actually be able to benefit from stricter privacy rules.

While TVREV Thought Leaders Circle had a variety of opinions on the potential fallout of the bill, one universal comment was that the bill is just a proposal, an opening volley in the upcoming privacy wars, if you will and that much would likely change before (and if) it became a law.

Michael Tuminello, Vice President, Strategy at Mediaocean looked at the key reasons why the TV industry was unlikely to suffer the same repercussions from the proposed bill as players like Google and Facebook, while advocating for a more transparent system that served the needs of buyers, sellers and consumers equally.

"I’m not sure which is more dramatic – the name of the Banning Surveillance Advertising Act, or its potential impact on the TV industry, but it’s probably the former. The bulk of TV and video advertising is not specifically targeted, and marketers can get a long way toward audience targeting with geographic and content signals alone, if it comes to that. In addition, the emerging major players in streaming TV – TV OS owners like Samsung, platforms like Roku, and content giants like NBCU and Disney – would likely operate under less scrutiny than the historical tech giants even under the law.  There are a number of reasons for this:

 

•  There is a lot more competition in the TV space compared to the couple of players dominating online advertising.

•  TV advertising will be harder to police.

•  Many TV providers have paid subscribers. They can dial back plans to profit off of audience data as needed.

•  TV ads are more expensive and harder to buy.

 

The newly recognized need to protect society as a whole from negatively impactful uses of consumer data is one of many reasons that the next generation of adtech needs to be defined by solutions that are built to serve buyers, sellers, and consumers. Such coordination will be needed to serve the needs and protect the interests of all three constituencies.  We believe Mediaocean is in a unique position to build the required media-neutral infrastructure that supports the consolidation of a too-fragmented ecosystem, as well as the required transparency to ensure the industry can put accountability on an equal footing with economic success."

 

Our TVREV take is that the bill is meant to highlight some of the more egregious privacy violations that vendors like Google and Facebook routinely engage in (scanning email) while taking advantage of the national mood that paints Big Tech as evil.

The television industry is largely immune from this, as targeted TV advertising, or CTV advertising, to be exact, is still in its nascency. That said, the industry needs to be conscious (and conscientious) about transparency and choosing solutions that do not raise potential privacy concerns. Contextual advertising seems to be an excellent vehicle for this, targeting the types of consumers who watch certain genres of programming, rather than the consumers themselves.

To wit, a recent study from Hub Research noted that consumers felt that targeted advertising on Discovery+ was less bothersome than on other platforms. Our suspicion is that is because Discovery’s home and food themed shows attract advertisers whose products are aligned with that sort of content, and so everything feels of a piece.

One final note: whatever happens to this particular bill, you can be sure that this will not be the last attempt to more strictly police the online advertising industry.

Read the full comments at TVRev

 

By Alan Wolk

Originally published by TVRev

Schedule a demo with Innovid

CONTACT US
logo
Solutions
AI
Creative Personalization
Social
Ad Serving
Audience & Identity
Creative Intelligence
Verification
Partners
Platform
Create
Automate
Activate
Iterate
Industries
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources
Creative Showcase
Reports
Events
Blog
Press Releases
Press Coverage
About
DE&I
Careers
Newsletter
Contact us
Support
Help Center
Ad Server Migration
Training
Creative Production
Workshops
Solutions   
Solutions
AI
Creative Personalization
Social
Ad Serving
Audience & Identity
Creative Intelligence
Verification
Partners
Platform   
Platform
Create
Automate
Activate
Iterate
Industries   
Industries
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources   
Resources
Creative Showcase
Reports
Events
Blog
Press Releases
Press Coverage
About   
About
DE&I
Careers
Newsletter
Contact us
Support   
Support
Help Center
Ad Server Migration
Training
Creative Production
Workshops
Youtube Icon
Privacy Policy
Your Privacy Choices
Modern Slavery Policy
Opt-Out
Publisher Certification
Submit Vulnerability Report or Bug
Terms and Conditions
©2025   Mediaocean