Skip to main content Skip to main content

Welcome to a new era of ad tech

Flashtalking + Innovid =

Innovid Logo
Learn more
X
Flashtalking Logo
Search
Solutions
Solutions
AI
Creative Personalization
Social
Ad Serving
Audience & Identity
Creative Intelligence
Verification
Partners
Platform
Platform
Create: Design & Build
Automate: Version & Feeds
Activate: Distribute & Traffic
Iterate: Learn & Optimize
Industries
Industries
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources
Resources
Creative Showcase
Reports
Events
Blog
Press Releases
Press Coverage
About
About
Diversity, equity, and inclusion
Careers
Contact Us
Newsletter
Support
Support
Help Center
Ad Server Migration
Flashtalking Training
Creative Production Services
Strategic Planning Workshops
Contact Us
Log in to Innovid
Home
Solutions
Solutions
Innovid unleashes the power of creative in advertising with AI.
AI
Better business outcomes powered by AI
Creative Personalization
Real-time relevancy at scale across social, open web, and CTV
Social
Advanced automation in a unified platform
Ad Serving
Independent, unbiased delivery across open web and CTV
Audience & Identity
Cookieless measurement and personalization
Creative Intelligence
Insights connecting content and performance
Verification
Holistic brand protection
Partners
Integrations across the ecosystem
Platform
Platform
Innovid connects the silos across teams, processes, and technology.
Create: Design & Build
Make it beautiful. Creative Tools
Automate: Version & Feeds
Make it scale. Creative Versioning Creative Labels
Activate: Distribute & Traffic
Make it connect. SocialOpen Web & CTV
Iterate: Learn & Optimize
Make it better.Operational Dashboards & Reporting
Industries
Industries
We build trusted partnerships with global advertisers through our deep industry expertise.
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources
Resources
Catch up on the latest events, announcements, and thought leadership from the Innovid team.
Creative Showcase
Best-in-class omnichannel executions and client success stories
Reports
Industry trends and best practices
Events
Upcoming engagements and featured recordings
Blog
Insights and thought leadership from our team
Press Releases
Official company announcements
Press Coverage
Industry publications featuring Innovid
About
About
Innovid is part of Mediaocean, the foundational partner for omnichannel advertising.
Diversity, equity, and inclusion
Diversity of thought and experience makes us stronger.
Careers
Explore open roles and discover how we bring our passion to work every day.
Newsletter
Keep up-to-date with news, industry trends, events, and more.
Contact Us
We want to hear from you!
Support
Support
As your trusted partner, count on us for strategic and creative services, platform certification, and more.
Help Center
Task-level eLearning, articles, on-demand webinars, and technical content
Ad Server Migration
Seamless migration process back by our experienced client solutions teams
Innovid Training
Self-paced credential programs and instructor-led training
Creative Production Services
Creative expertise from our team of designers and producers
Strategic Planning Workshops
Collaborative sessions to strategize across brand, creative, and media teams
Contact us
  • Why Apple’s Anti-Tracking Move Hurts Everyone … But Apple

    Steve Latham
    12 Sep 2020
    Steve Latham
    12 Sep 2020
    Apple recently announced a new privacy feature that will ask iPhone and iPad users to opt in or opt out of tracking for in-app advertising. While most applaud Apple for its pro-privacy stance, there’s much more to the story. Flashtalking’s Steve Latham examines how Apple’s move will hurt publishers and consumers for its own financial gain.

Apple recently announced a new privacy feature that will ask iPhone and iPad users to opt-in or opt-out of tracking for in-app advertising.  While most applaud Apple for its pro-privacy stance, there’s much more to the story. As I’ll explain below, Apple’s move will hurt publishers and consumers for its own financial gain. The truth is that Apple’s virtue-signaling is masking anti-competitive behavior that needs to be called out.

The first domino

Apple announced in June that iOS14 (due later this month) would prompt users to opt-in/out of tracking by advertisers in third-party apps on their iPhones and iPads. It’s not hard to see why most expect users to opt-out en masse. How ominous is this warning?

When a user selects “Ask App Not to Track,” it disables an anonymous identifier known as the ID for Advertisers (IDFA). Once the IDFA is disabled, app developers and publishers can no longer make that identifier available to advertisers seeking to deliver relevant ads to users. While it seems rather innocuous, it will set off a chain of events that will end badly for everyone but Apple and Google.

 

Harm to publishers and developers

Articles have covered how this will hurt advertisers. While few will take pity on advertisers, what about your favorite news, weather, music, fitness, gaming, or meditation app? Disabling the IDFA will devastate ad-supported apps because it’s the IDFA that makes their media valuable to advertisers. If you’re a luxury apparel brand for women, you’re targeting a very narrow set of users, and you’re willing to pay more to reach them. In this example, apps that serve ads to affluent females (anonymously identified by their IDFA) can charge a 2-3x premium for that ad. Without IDFAs to target ads to relevant audiences, prices will plummet by 50-70%, making ad-supported models untenable.

Of the 2.2 million apps in the Apple store, many will fail as ad revenue nosedives. Apps that are able to migrate to subscription models will pay a high price. Aside from the costly development work and the inevitable loss of users, publishers will have to pay Apple a 30% tax on new subscription revenue. This is where Apple crosses the line into monopolistic behavior—more on that below.

 

Harm to consumers

When ad supported content is no longer viable, consumers will have to pay for content. While very few say they like ads, most realize we need them. A recent NAI study found that 75% of consumers are aware that free content is enabled by advertising. Moreover, 64% of consumers believe online content should be free. So we expect free ad-supported content, but we don’t want to share data that makes ad models work? Actually the problem isn’t advertisers. The NAI study also found that the #1 privacy concern is data collection by hackers, not publishers. Guess who else knows this and stands to benefit from the death of the free content?  Well … you know the answer.

So to recap: Apple knows that disabling IDFAs will kill ad models and force publishers to migrate to subscriptions for which Apple will collect 30%. Apple also knows this will require us to pay for content (such as Apple News+ at $9.99/month) that we fundamentally expect for free. Are you getting the picture yet?

When Steve Jobs introduced the iPhone in 2007, he proclaimed that this was “the Internet in your pocket,” and a transformational step for the growth of online publishing. I don’t recall his desiring to be a 21st century railroad baron. The decapitation of the IDFA threatens the viability of the open mobile web while imperiling the very ecosystem that made Apple’s devices so magical in the first place. Is this really the future Jobs envisioned in 2007?

I’m a longtime fan, customer, and shareholder of Apple. I admire Tim Cook and the company’s ethos. But we have to call this out for what it is. If Apple simply wants to offer more privacy protection, there are less subversive ways to do it. Intentional or not, Apple is using privacy as an excuse to stifle competition and harm consumers for its own benefit.

 

What else can we expect?

For starters, Google is likely to follow suit—quickly. Once Apple has transitioned apps to fee-generating subscription models, Google will be right behind it, with 2.8 million apps in the Google Play store.

We can also expect more lawsuits. Following Epic Games’ lawsuit against Apple, Google, and Samsung, more and more apps will file suit for anti-competitive practices.

Lastly, the government will have to intervene. While the FTC and DOJ have been very accommodating to date, the domino effect will require a federal response. For reference, the FTC prohibits conduct by a single firm that unreasonably restrains competition by creating or maintaining monopoly power. Specific examples might include:

 

Exclusive supply or purchase agreements: 

IPhone/iPad app distribution and/or downloading can only occur via the App store. Violate terms and find yourself persona non grata across 800 million devices.

Tying arrangements: 

Prohibiting mobile commerce outside the App ecosystem in which publishers must share revenue with Apple.

Lack of alternatives:

If you want to reach iPhones, you must pass through the App store. It’s the same for consumers seeking Apps.

Predatory pricing: 

Is 30% reasonable? Go ask Fortnite.

 

Stay of execution

Last week, Apple announced it will postpone implementation of the anti-tracking feature until early 2021. It cited the fact that ad-supported developers and publishers were not yet prepared (quite the understatement). While this stay is helpful, it only delays the inevitable—unless we act.

 

Call to action

Now more than ever, the advertising, publishing, and developer communities must start working together on two critical fronts:

 

1. Communicate the exchange of value when we consume free ad-supported content. 

Each time I visit a page or open an app, I should be informed that anonymous tracking enables the publisher to generate ad revenue to provide free content. By allowing the site to track me, I’m supporting their business. If I choose not to opt-in for tracking by (pick a date), I will have to subscribe to view the content. I should then be directed to a page that clearly and succinctly states what data is being tracked (e.g. anonymous or personal) and how it will and will not be used. Explain the tradeoffs and allow me to make an informed decision. It’s common sense.

 

2. Lobby Apple to change the language in its opt-in/opt-out prompt. 

As currently written, users are going to opt-out of tracking in droves. But what if it read something like this, instead?

"This app relies on an anonymous identifier to provide relevant advertising that supports free content. You may opt-out now or in the future. Learn more: visit PalAbout/Privacy."

 

I believe Apple should prioritize helping users make informed decisions rather than scaring them down the path to paid content.

I’m hopeful that Apple will act in good faith and work with the industry to balance privacy with the interests of consumers, publishers, and advertisers. But it will not happen on its own. As they say, speak now or forever hold your peace. Because once this occurs, the damage will be hard to undo.

 

By Steve Latham, Global Head of Analytics

Originally published by Venture Beat

Schedule a demo with Innovid

CONTACT US
logo
Solutions
AI
Creative Personalization
Social
Ad Serving
Audience & Identity
Creative Intelligence
Verification
Partners
Platform
Create
Automate
Activate
Iterate
Industries
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources
Creative Showcase
Reports
Events
Blog
Press Releases
Press Coverage
About
DE&I
Careers
Newsletter
Contact us
Support
Help Center
Ad Server Migration
Training
Creative Production
Workshops
Solutions   
Solutions
AI
Creative Personalization
Social
Ad Serving
Audience & Identity
Creative Intelligence
Verification
Partners
Platform   
Platform
Create
Automate
Activate
Iterate
Industries   
Industries
Automotive
CPG
Financial Services
Retail
Sports Betting
Travel
Video Gaming
Resources   
Resources
Creative Showcase
Reports
Events
Blog
Press Releases
Press Coverage
About   
About
DE&I
Careers
Newsletter
Contact us
Support   
Support
Help Center
Ad Server Migration
Training
Creative Production
Workshops
Youtube Icon
Privacy Policy
Your Privacy Choices
Modern Slavery Policy
Opt-Out
Publisher Certification
Submit Vulnerability Report or Bug
Terms and Conditions
©2025   Mediaocean